Not all appraisals (anywhere) will be "a million dollars! You hit the jackpot!" - If that's what you are looking for then you are not in the right place. If however, you are looking for an honest expert appraisal, then you came to the right place.
my personal belief is if you had no dash in the domain name, it would have raised the value that people would put on the domain by itself as well as on the domain+website. Dashes hurt domain values. I liked your site, but I would have rather the domain did not have a dash. It is a decent market and you should do well if you can get traffic, but you will need to search engine optimize it as fewer people type in domain names with dashes than without. As such, the above appraisal is about good as it will get for the domain name without a website.