Originally posted by mole
I'm sure a lot of domains drop because the admin contact lost his/her/their email somehow, somewhere.
That's why grabbing dropped domains can be classified as "stealing" in a way.
Here I cannot agree - "stealing" implies an "unlawful" act designed to deprive the "lawful" owner of something. If a name drops then it has been through the "lawful" routine of expiry and redemption period and the owner has the opportunity to renew, having been reminded by his or her registrar.
On the other hand, using an obtained email address to take a name that is currently active and in use by another is clearly theft. I am currently involved with the UK police, the FBI and the police in another country concerning the theft of domains which were subsequently sold to me by a Platinum member of this board. These names were obtained in this same way, ie obtaining an admin email address and "unlawfully" transferring them away from the owner's account.
It might have seemed clever at the time but by weeks of research and investigation I have been able to clearly identify the trail of the names and identify the Platinum board member concerned - the files are now with the UK Police and that Platinum member will soon find out just how clever those thefts really were.