I've had transfers from various registrars to enom within 24 hours. (of course pushes are done in seconds)
Then again, I've had over a dozen failed transfer requests (and paid fees) trying to get a name out of the hands of Abacus / Aplusnet/ Names4ever, taking about 3 months. Get this, I was trying to transfer one of my own names to myself!
If they can't figure out their own name, what would make me think they could do any better with mine?