Itrader rating

[Namefox]

Hi all. I made an offer on a domain and he accepted. Something quickly changed where I didn't have the money anymore, I backed out so this member left a negative itrader rating. I thought this system was only for transactions that have taken place i.e. payment made but domain pushed.

I have always made a point of honoring my word and now my precious 100% rating is now tarnished. Do I have any recourse?

 

[Sonny Banks]

Pm mods.

 

[lotk.com]

I have had several offers from members here that I have accepted and then the buyers just don't respond to my PMs, but I definitely wouldn't leave a negative itrader for it. The best thing for you to do is pm mods like Carter said. Good luck.

 

[theinvestor]

Hi all. I made an offer on a domain and he accepted. Something quickly changed where I didn't have the money anymore, I backed out so this member left a negative itrader rating. I thought this system was only for transactions that have taken place i.e. payment made but domain pushed.

I have always made a point of honoring my word and now my precious 100% rating is now tarnished. Do I have any recourse?

Technically speaking if someone makes an offer and you accept negotiations are done and now it's either a verbal or written contract. You then backed out of the deal meaning you didn't follow the contract. So the negative feedback is just i can't see why it would be removed.

On a side note, i have had members here make offers on my domains and then not respond or change their mind. I did not leave a negative but i will never do business with them again.

 

[Namefox]

Thanks gentleman for your advice. It is not that big of an issue but I really was proud of my 100% itrader rating.

 

[Chuck]

Hi all. I made an offer on a domain and he accepted. Something quickly changed where I didn't have the money anymore, I backed out so this member left a negative itrader rating. I thought this system was only for transactions that have taken place i.e. payment made but domain pushed.

I have always made a point of honoring my word and now my precious 100% rating is now tarnished. Do I have any recourse?

That's a tough one!

I have no doubts something really did come up with you that you know longer had the money but it's similar to a non paying bidder on ebay, which sellers leave negative feedback for as well.

If the seller wishes to withdraw the feedback, as you have a great reputation here, then I will glady remove it.

Chuck

 

[HuntingMoon]

Leave it- once you make an offer it should be binding or there is no honor. When I am in Japan you pay for beer in one line and then wait in a separate line and they ask you how many you paid for a la the honor system. in this case you have a documented offer. unless you have a doctor's note or something similar, i am in complete and total agreement with the negative feedback.

 

[Sleepys]

I have no doubts something really did come up with you that you know longer had the money but it's similar to a non paying bidder on ebay, which sellers leave negative feedback for as well.

Actually, ebay recently stopped allowing sellers to leave a negative or even a neutral rating for buyer, regardless of the reason. Buyers can still leave a negative, but sellers can only leave a positive (if they want). Just more proof that ebay does not care about its sellers.

 

[Gileyal]

Sorry to hear man. You do have a great record. Maybe try to talk to the guy, apologize for what happened and explain the situation? There's a chance he'll calm down and remove the negative comment.

 

[Chuck]

Update....buyer and seller are working this out. Good job!