The idea of a "traffic forum" is nice, but if even only a few people abuse the new forum, its credibility will be shot...that is no one will ever trust what they read in there anymore after that.
Also, "link-in" counts and "occurrance" counts measure somewhat different things; worse both of these values can vary considerably dpending on what service is used - and even within the same search engine service due to geotargeting and other misc factors.
Only real way to measure traffic is counting it d
But counting it isn't so simple...is it type-in, link-in, and variation thereof. What about traffic manipulation? And what is considered a "unique" hit? (many different people share the same IP) ... and count Homepage hits only or all pages? So many questions!
Even on domains where the traffic is well known, the quality of the traffic can vary widely; one may get the mistaken impression that traffic itself equals value...there are numerous domains that get little traffic, but are still quite valuable...for example, single (1) letter (there no single numeric ones from what I recall) domains.
A better way quite really is to do what Afternic and other lesser known services do and categorize domains ... Afternic's categories seem to actually work very well and it's easy to find what one desires (their search engine is a different story though - has some serious glitches).
In short, instead of a "traffic forum", consider category forums instead...also that would scale much nicer - that is allow far more domains to be advertised here.
Ron