That makes no sense. I asked for your experience in appraising domain names. How many of those domain names have sold at (or above) the value you came up with? Otherwise anyone can just make up a price and be as valid as yours. ALL paid appraisals are worthless and free appraisals should all be taken as subjective - ie opinion. Anyone making an appraisal should explain why they think it's worth that and maybe discussion can ensue. But anyone can sign up new to the forum, say 'my experience says $xx,xxx' and it is meaningless without an explanation.