=== Should F$ transaction be allowed for TR Feedback?? ===

[Johnn]

Question of the day:

Should F$ transaction be allowed for TR feedback?

I just want to know your opinion. Yes or No and Why?

The reason being because I got an offer from a member here and he/she has a lot of feedbacks but it turned out that all the feedbacks came from F$ transactions.

I did refuse the offer.

Thanks,
John

 

[oveber]

I think no.
Many member has alot of F$ to sell and get alt of positiv feebacks.

 

[jasdon11]

I think yes.

What's the difference between selling F$ and a $2 .info

 

[scrsteven]

I'd say No.

 

[Johnn]

There is a difference.

Normal transaction reuired that you have funds from your Paypal or Bank.
F$ transactions required nothing but posting to earn F$.

The reason I turned down the offer because the paypal account is no verified and just created today.

 

[jasdon11]

There is a difference.

Normal transaction reuired that you have funds from your Paypal or Bank.
F$ transactions required nothing but posting to earn F$.

The reason I turned down the offer because the paypal account is no verified and just created today.

Sorry, I misunderstood. I thought you meant buying F$ with real $ - not buying names with F$. In that case, no.

 

[Thomas Nash]

No i dont think TR's should be allowed, it could be to easily abused and you could easily get lots of TR's without actually dealing with money.

 

[Biggie]

No i dont think TR's should be allowed, it could be to easily abused and you could easily get lots of TR's without actually dealing with money.

exactly!

my opinion as well.

 

[PeterMan]

I am a little confused by what you are asking.

Are you saying that someone contacted you and said I will give you F$ if you post positive feedback?

Or

are you saying if you sell a domain to someone and they pay using F$ you do not think that TR rating should apply?

 

[Johnn]

This guy/gal has been here since Feb/2007 and has a lot of feedback (F$ transaction).
He made an offer on several names ($xxx total) and asked me to send him/her a Paypal invoice.
I checked the Paypal email and found out that the paypal account is not verified as it was created yesterday with no prior transaction. I sent an email asking why the paypal is created yesterday and did not get any reply.

I turned down the offer anyhow.

How can we propose to DNF so to make it a rule not to allow TR feedback for F$ transaction?

John

I am a little confused by what you are asking.

Are you saying that someone contacted you and said I will give you F$ if you post positive feedback?

Or

are you saying if you sell a domain to someone and they pay using F$ you do not think that TR rating should apply?

If you use F$ for any type of transactions then you should not be allowed to give or receive TR feedback.

 

[Devil Dog]

Good looking out.

Sounds fishy.

Might not be, but you never know.

 

[GAMEFINEST]

Thats a negative

 

[fkrule]

yes thats like saying only card payments on ebay should get a TR

 

[Theo]

Verified Paypal accounts only exist in the US, Canada and UK. Maybe France as well.

 

[Poohnix]

Verified Paypal accounts only exist in the US, Canada and UK. Maybe France as well.

I don't know if there are any difference in what they mean by "verified", but my account has always had the status "Swedish - Verified" (Business account)
In my business I have thousands of transactions from users all over the world, and almost all of them have "verified" accounts, according to PayPal. (There seems to be two kinds, "US -Verified", and "Non-US - Verified". The same no matter which Non-US country they are from)
It's possible to deny payments from unverified accounts, but in my regular business the transactions amounts aren't very high.

 

[GiantDomains]

They are allowed beause they are deals that happen on the forum, and the TR system does not scan the thread to see what was used to pay. So... yes.

 

[Theo]

I don't know if there are any difference in what they mean by "verified", but my account has always had the status "Swedish - Verified" (Business account)
In my business I have thousands of transactions from users all over the world, and almost all of them have "verified" accounts, according to PayPal. (There seems to be two kinds, "US -Verified", and "Non-US - Verified". The same no matter which Non-US country they are from)
It's possible to deny payments from unverified accounts, but in my regular business the transactions amounts aren't very high.

Sorry, I was talking about "confirmed address". This is only available in the US, UK and Canada. Verification entails adding a bank account.

 

[VirtualT]

Sorry, I was talking about "confirmed address". This is only available in the US, UK and Canada. Verification entails adding a bank account.

add Australia, I confirmed one mine with address, took about 3 weeks for the letter to arrive