five minutes passed and thread bashers just can't resist....
ok lets take usatoday - case study -
yes they now advertise m.usatoday.com. But whois shows they also regd usatoday.mobi. will they stick with m.xxxx, revert to mobi, do both? But, this is key, its one company!!!
other BIG businesses are using .mobi daily! can we estimate a decent (can we use the term significant?) percentage of business will use .mobi - so what if some don't - free world and they might down the road, probably have the names already or will get them. and they might if other do and it snowballs and it really catches on.
multiple phones/platforms/carriers will continue - did everyone buy the star tec, treo, blackberry, motorola razr when they came out? razr was $600? the cool cologne changed (my day drakar, cool water, safari, ck, hugo, list goes on and on - I'm Faragamo now, usually nothing). the diet fads go by and even have revivals (I fought with a colleague that Atkins wouldn't be a fad - I was into it then and I was WRONG; now the fight's do all vodka's taste the same) does everyone have that phone now? are people locked into service plans, will they continue for various reasons/incentives, will businesses all hand out the same phones, will they be iphones? Also we haven't bought the iphone yet. how's the battery life, weight, sound quality, durability, etc etc. The iphone hasnt proven itself yet at all (anyone have presales order numbers-i'm sure their coming from the haters-again far off point). But point is it will not take the majority of market share. the shitty gphone may. who knows. And, my dad will not get the iphone, neither will my nephew, my best friend might, he may go to the movies with his girlfriend who may not and they might use .mobi that night. how may people live in a city. I live in NY. Will a significant number of people use .mobi despite iphones? yes
forget the premise that .mobi will best .com or that it will rule the world. Start here - it seems clear that it hasn't even started yet. Is it ready for burial with thousands of companys yet to go live? the tv ads, the billboards and playbills to start? when did every commercial on tv start putting .coms on the bottom, only the last couple years (generous?) Argue if it will become dominant and such, but .mobi will become significant in that a significant amount of people will use if on a significant number of varied platforms. Some will use it and some won't .. The basic argument is 1+1=2. The nail in the coffin people seem to have selective blindness/tunnel vision with their own agendas.