Well, Godaddy Guy seems to have abandoned ship on us.
I've done my research and now have the results.
Domain: refinancerebate.com
1) 2 days ago, I backordered this domain in my reseller sub-account.
2) 1 day ago, I backordered this domain in my Godaddy account.
3) Today, the domain dropped and was caught by Godaddy.
4) I received an email from my reseller account that "Godaddy failed to acquire the domain".
5) I received an email from my Godaddy account that "Godaddy SUCCESSFULLY acquired the domain".
So now I can answer the questions that Godaddy support and Godaddy Guy refused to answer. They are basically screwing over the resellers and they reseller customers. ANY backorder and ANY time placed in a non-reseller account wins over any backorder in a reseller account, even when the reseller backorder is placed first.
Bad move, Godaddy, you should be supporting your resellers, not taking from them.