"What I do not understand is why people who visit the forums via
http://www.dnforum.com and are not members cannot read the forums, yet those who search on past records on a domain name who are end users (ie. Joe goes to google as he wants to buy xyz.com from me and sees that I had it for sale at one point for $$$ but he would be willing to pay $$$$$, that would make it harder to get Joe to pay $$$$$ because he sees it was once for sale for lower..) can see the posts no problem"
Too funny. To true. And the answer is simple. They will never get another fee from a new member. The SE query is supposed to at least make them aware of the site. Get em to visit. Maybe they'll join. They obviously cant browse, respond, to all the posts or communicate with other members without a mship. However a quick whois will certainly come in handy. But really, the value of a, well, non-private platinum membership should surely suffer. Many pros and cons to this scenerio for all involved. All you can do is act accordingly. Allowing the indexing by SE , in my opinion, should at least not include previous posts , before the decision was made to allow indexing. Thats only fair, if its possible.