I hope that in most of these cases the names are being awarded because of trademark violations, not because of one being famous?
I am a Domainer and to be honest I will always give the Domainers side, no matter what, this is after all a business, everything is far in love and war, and Domaining business is kinda war.
First off, no matter what the other person argued, Scarlett Johansson would still have legitimate rights to the domain name. End of case.
*the exceptional businesses of our esteemed moderators