SNIP - For example, wouldn't concerttickets.com/mobi work as well as concerttickets.mobi? Also wouldn't it seem logical that future sites would recognize a visit by a mobile device and display the appropriate design? - SNIP
That is really the point of discussion.
While some that that it is or that it will be possible to simply have a page optimized for a mobile device tucked away on your current dot common, the question is:
Does your VISITOR know that?
Will he/she know to go to gopc.com/mobi and find a page that actually works on their portable? Or will I, as the domain owner, have to build a mobi compatible home page (that shows well on a mobile but looks like crap on a desktop) for the visitor to choose their platform?
Or....
Is it just as easy to drop some ching, but the mobi ext and simply point it to my dot common domain page that is optimized for mobiles?
Remember, the big marketing push for these huge corporations vested in mobi is the fact that ".mobi means it will work on your portable". That is, .mobi domains are and will be marketed specifically for mobile users with the notion that if you are mobile, you use .mobi, if you are not, use the dot commons.
Also, considering the fact that these vested interests control not only the ext, but the devices, the manufacturing, the software, the integrated browsers, the content provision, the searching, the content results and the contenct servers in many cases.... Many have concluded that due to the diffuculty typing domains and whatnot into a mobile may result in a forced DEFAULT ext of .mobi
I think (there's that speculation word again) that it will go deeper than that. I think these companies have build mobi to also be a limitless advertising platform for themselves. Default ext, sure, makes sense... but what about preselling default searches, preprogrammed quick keys, softkeys and catagorical landers? All of these reserved for .mobi customers and pages.
It's the natural progression of the mobile internet... just as contextual advertising is for the desktop Internet. The founders/investors of .mobi have a vested interest in ensuring that .mobi is successful in order to build a PPC/advertising platform that, like the mobile internet itself, is on a contained platform exclusive to them.
As for making a script to convert regular pages to mobiles... sure, that makes sense. But also remember... the Mobile Internet was NEVER designed to be the SAME as the desktop internet.
I don't think the goal is to bring the 'net to the phones... but rather bring phones to the net through a controlled interface that is .MOBI.
Thus the agreements to maintain a standardized .mobi design spec or the threat of loosing your domain.
The writing is on the wall. Those that are trying to compare it to and define it by the current desktop internet are not going to "get it". Those that see it as the formation of a NEW internet, a MOBILE internet, that accesses part of, that lives independantly of the desktop internet... DO get it.
And if, no.. WHEN the other shoe drops and the general public discovers that .mobi actually IS the mobile internet and that compliant .mobi domain are given preference if not exclusivity to that mobile internet, THEN you will see the true power and value of the new extension they have created.
Length of words, phrases and domains wont matter. Most of them will be presented to the user directly off of the .mobi database, catagorized by Google and presented through the participating cellular networks such as Vodaphone, T-Moble, Telefonica on phones preprogrammed by Nokia, Ericsson, Sansung with content provision by Microsoft and more.
Just look at the structure... It's all there. My cell has a QWERT keyboard IF... I say IF domains are to be typed in... but I think it'll be more convenient than that... point and click is the future of the mobi, Just like an automated phone menu, only for visual data.
If you want this, press 1, if you want that, press 2... and so on.
We're ALREADY programmed to work that way on a phone.
The standards for .mobi state that links should have numberical shortcuts for them.
It's all in place. The stage has been set...
Mobi, as I say, is the sound of Inevitability.
GoPC.mobi