Hi Slaich!
Still here?
With all respect:
Some postings are correct - Some not.
There are no "Crappy Domains", no Crappy Cars, No Crappy Homes, No Crappy Whatever.
It is all between the ears.
It is not ---> What is item xxx "Worth?"
But it is ---> What is item xxx "Worth for You".
Most coments on domain forums are from reseller viewpoint.
End users handle usually individual criteria and don't care about third party opinions.
We should not forget that value is individual.
Whatever the price of any item in a shop, on a market, on line: The seller must create tempting conditions.
Tempting condition
#1 is Not Price but Availability.
About "Crappy Domains":
Any domain can be used for anything!
Examples:
Yahoo.com: Well, we know a Yahoo is ...
Tucows.com: What is a Tucow? It is just about Two Cows ...
DogPile.com: Haha ... It works!
GoDaddy.com: Nothing about domains in the SLD, but succesful in domaining.
About archive.org:
It doesn't matter what a domain has been used for previously.
It is not the shop but current product, presentation & Price.
There are no "Crappy Domains".
The strangest character combinations have been used for successful businesses.
Here some quite easy lecture:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_value
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_market_value
Just remember the sentences about "... willing buyer" and "... without pressure".
In domain business, there's always pressure ...
To have a nice SERP for a website, plenty relevant content is necessary.
Good posts, but we must remind that what works for one does not necessarily work for somebody else.
Also, if You buy a domein + website, any modification usually changes SERP.
May I suggest to Google for: scientific domain appraisals.
Succes, all!